New York City Car Rental: Expert Tips for Big Savings

Petr Novk

For cheap car rental in New York, I advise you to utilize the car rental service at JFK airport, which is the most affordable in my comparison. Nevertheless, New York is one of the most expensive cities in the USA in terms of rental price.

New York City Car Rental: Expert Tips for Big Savings

For a no-obligation car rental price quote, I recommend using the following form, which compares prices from several rental car companies across different locations in New York City.

Car Rental Price in New York City

The price of car rental in New York is influenced by several factors:

Duration of Rental

During certain times of the year, rental cars are in higher demand, leading to a rise in rental prices.

When to Book?

Based on my comparison, it’s best to book a car two to three months in advance of your intended trip.

Location of the Car Rental Company

Lower rental prices are usually found at the airport due to more competition, while the higher prices are typically in the city centre.

Car Category

The most affordable cars are in the economy class, which can still accommodate 5 people without any issues. Mid-range cars, SUVs or convertibles are more comfortable but more expensive.

Driver’s Age

For drivers under 25, most rental companies charge an additional fee.

Insurance Included

The price is significantly influenced by the included insurances, which range from basic compulsory liability to car loss insurance. Personally, I recommend not skimping on insurance.

Accessories

For an additional fee, the rental company offers GPS navigation (recommended), satellite radio (not recommended), or a child car seat. The price is per day of rental.

Before booking, compare prices from several car rental companies in New York City and the surrounding area, not just one. RentalCars.com always compares quotes from more than 200 rental companies with a lowest price guarantee.

The table below displays the cheapest car rentals in New York of different classes for one day.

Economy Middle SUV Convertible
Cheap Car Rental in New York City Car Rental in New York SUV Rental in New York Convertible Rental in NYC
from $42 from $41 from $49 from $92
Get a Quote Get a Quote Get a Quote Get a Quote

Cheap Car Rentals in New York City

JFK Airport rentals offer the broadest selection and lowest prices, with Advantage, Alamo, Avis, Budget, Dollar, Enterprise, Hertz, National, Payless, and Thrifty. Some of these are open 24/7 throughout the week.

Advantage, Alamo, Avis, Budget, Dollar, Enterprise, Hertz, National, Payless, and Thrifty also have locations at LaGuardia Airport. While LaGuardia primarily serves domestic flights and flights to Canada, some rental agencies are open 24 hours a day.

Car Rentals in Manhattan, the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, and other New York City boroughs are usually smaller, with a smaller selection of cars. These include AAMCAR Car Rental, AllCar Rent-A-Car, Avis Car Rental, Budget Car Rental, Dollar Rent a Car, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Prestige Car Rental, and Thrifty Car Rental. Based on my comparison, their prices are typically higher than those of airport car rental companies.

Road Trip Tips from New York City

Niagara Falls is one of the most popular attractions in the US. The drive from New York City to the falls is over 398 mi of highways and takes approximately six and a half hours one way. Interestingly, you do not leave New York State the entire time.

You can also head southwest to the US capital. Washington D.C. is approximately 229 mi from the center of Manhattan, and the journey takes around four and a half hours one way.

For a longer and more picturesque road trip, consider the 1,445 mi journey along the Atlantic to sunny Florida. Stretching across ten US states, the route takes over 22 hours of driving time and gives you the opportunity to visit several US National Parks along the way.

Save on Car Rentals in the USA